ABC’s “20/20” opts for a decidedly unromantic Valentine’s Day offering, trading chocolates and roses for a chilling tale of small-town deception and a mysterious death. “Small Town, Big Con” examines the case of Michael and Natalie Cochran, high school sweethearts turned alleged fraudsters, whose seemingly idyllic life in Beckley, West Virginia, took a dark and deadly turn.
Initially, the Cochrans appeared to be living the American dream – successful business owners, generous neighbors, and pillars of their community. But beneath the veneer of prosperity lurked a web of lies, a Ponzi scheme that allegedly defrauded friends and neighbors out of their life savings. Then, at the age of 38, Michael Cochran died suddenly. A tragic accident? Or something more sinister?
As Deborah Roberts investigates, the story unfolds with the grim fascination of a slow-burn thriller. Interviews with neighbors like Chris and Jennifer Davis, who invested heavily in the Cochrans’ business, reveal the devastating impact of the alleged fraud. Law enforcement officials, including retired West Virginia State Police Capt. Tim Bledsoe and financial investigator Robert Hinzman, provide insights into the elaborate scheme. Even Michael’s mother, Donna Bolt, offers a poignant perspective on the unraveling of her son’s life.
While the focus remains firmly on the alleged financial crimes and the lingering questions surrounding Michael’s death, the small-town setting adds an extra element of betrayal. The Cochrans weren’t just con artists; they were neighbors, friends, and members of a tight-knit community. Their alleged deception shattered trust and left a trail of financial ruin in its wake.
Tune in to ABC this Friday, February 14, from 9:01-11:00 p.m. EST for “Small Town, Big Con.” The episode will be available to stream on Hulu the following day.
“20/20” airs Fridays at 9:01 PM EST on ABC.
