The Basement: A Vanishing In Apple Valley Part 1 (5, Monday, April 7, 2025)

True Crime Port

The quiet town of Apple Valley, Ohio, becomes the setting for a disturbing mystery in the new two part true crime series “The Basement: A Vanishing In Apple Valley.” When Dairy Queen manager Tina Herrmann fails to show up for work, a colleague goes to check on her, only to discover a horrific scene: Tina’s home is splattered with blood, suggesting a violent struggle. But Tina is nowhere to be found.

The disappearance quickly escalates when it becomes clear that Tina’s children, 13-year-old Sarah and 11-year-old Kody, are also missing. As police begin their investigation, a seemingly mundane clue – a Walmart receipt for duct tape, trash bags, and rope – leads them to a suspect: Matthew Hoffman. SWAT teams are dispatched to two addresses associated with Hoffman, but the question remains: does he know where Tina, Sarah, and Kody are? And where is their neighbor, Stephanie Sprang, who has also vanished?

RELATED:   Bad Romance: Betrayed (ABC, Tuesday, April 22, 2025)

“The Basement: A Vanishing in Apple Valley” presents a chilling race against time, as investigators grapple with a case filled with disturbing questions and few answers. The two-part series begins Monday, April 7 at 10:00 PM on 5.

Isabelle aka Izzy Jacobs is the features editor at memorabletv.com. Isabelle is particularly drawn to crime dramas, but she also has a not so secret love for all things reality TV. In addition to her work at memorabletv.com, Isabelle is also an avid traveler and a devoted foodie.