Crime Nation: Long Island Murders (The CW, Thursday, April 3, 2025)

Crime Nation Key Art

“Crime Nation” returns to The CW this Thursday, tackling a case that continues to haunt Long Island and grip true crime followers: the unsolved Gilgo Four murders. While a suspect was apprehended in 2022, the question remains – was he acting alone?

This episode re-examines the evidence, looking beyond the arrest to explore the possibility of another killer still at large. The case, with its chilling details and lingering questions, has fueled speculation and amateur investigations for years. “Crime Nation,” however, goes beyond the online chatter, bringing a journalistic lens to the story and featuring insights from experts, law enforcement, and those closest to the victims. Is there more to this story than the official narrative suggests? Is another dark force still out there?

RELATED:   American Idol: Top 24 at Disney's Aulani Resort in Hawaii Part #2 (ABC, Monday, April 14, 2025)

“Crime Nation” raises unsettling questions about the true nature of these crimes, challenging the notion of closure and reminding us that some mysteries remain stubbornly resistant to easy answers. Find out Thursday, April 3rd at 9:00 PM ET on The CW.

Andrew Martins, reviewer, recapper, deep diver, scifi specialist. Thinks Blakes 7 is better than Star Trek. Yes I do go to fan conventions and no I don't dress up. Well okay maybe I do a bit.