Thirty years after Susan Smith’s infamous crime, “Dateline” revisits the tragic case in a two-hour special, “Return to the Lake.” The episode provides a fresh look at the events of 1994, looking into the story with renewed focus on the aftermath and ongoing impact of her horrific act.
“Dateline” secures an exclusive interview with David Smith, Susan’s ex-husband, who speaks candidly to NBC News’ Craig Melvin about Susan’s recent parole denial and the enduring pain of losing his two sons. In a chilling revelation, Smith admits to Melvin that he “wanted an eye for an eye,” expressing his preference for Susan’s execution.
The special weaves together archival interrogation audio, providing a gripping firsthand account of the initial investigation, with perspectives from those closest to the case, including Smith’s defense attorney, David’s current wife, and the Chief of SLED.
It airs Friday, February 14, 2025 at 9/8c on NBC.
