True crime has become ubiquitous, practically a genre unto itself. Every streamer seems to have a stable of docuseries exploring gruesome murders and baffling mysteries. But sometimes, even amidst the glut of content, a case emerges that’s truly chilling, a case that makes you wonder how it escaped wider notice for so long. Enter Herb Baumeister, the subject of Hulu’s new four-part docuseries, “The Fox Hollow Murders.”
Baumeister, a seemingly ordinary businessman from Indiana, led a double life that included a penchant for picking up men at gay bars and, allegedly, murdering them. The number of potential victims is staggering, possibly exceeding even that of Jeffrey Dahmer.
This docuseries isn’t just about recounting the grisly details; it follows Hamilton County coroner Jeff Jellison as he examines thousands of bone fragments discovered on Baumeister’s property. With the help of new DNA technology, Jellison hopes to finally identify the victims and bring closure to their families.
This isn’t just another true crime story; it’s a look into the mind of a predator, an exploration of how someone can maintain a facade of normalcy while committing unspeakable acts. And, perhaps most importantly, it’s an attempt to give a voice to the voiceless, to ensure that the victims of Herb Baumeister are not forgotten.
“The Fox Hollow Murders: Playground of a Serial Killer” begins streaming Tuesday, February 18 on Hulu.
