Hallmark’s holiday-themed mystery series, Mistletoe Murders, is officially coming back for a second season in 2025. The show, which blends Christmas cheer with crime-solving, proved a hit with viewers.
Here’s the Lowdown: Mistletoe Murders stars Sarah Drew as Emily Lane, a small-town store owner who investigates local murders. The cast also includes Peter Mooney, Sierra Marilyn Riley, Jean Yoon, Lara Amersey, and Kylee Evans. The renewal follows a successful first season and a season finale that left viewers with a major cliffhanger: “Who is Emily Lane?”.
What This Means Now: Fans of the show can expect another season of holiday-themed mysteries set in the town of Fletcher’s Grove. Hallmark executives specifically cited the blend of Christmas and mystery as a key factor in the show’s success and the decision to renew.
The Bigger Picture: The renewal reflects Hallmark’s continued investment in original series that combine popular genres. The positive response to Mistletoe Murders demonstrates the audience’s appetite for this kind of programming, blending cozy holiday settings with suspenseful storylines. A premiere date for the second season has yet to be announced.
