New York Homicide: The Coney Island Cover Up (Oxygen, Saturday, May 24, 2025)

New York Homicide Key Art

Oxygen True Crime is back on the beat this weekend with a fresh episode of New York Homicide, this time zeroing in on a grim discovery near Brooklyn’s iconic boardwalk.

Titled “The Coney Island Cover Up,” the May 24 episode unpacks the NYPD’s response to the death of a pregnant woman found barefoot and unresponsive near Coney Island. The case sets off a pressure-cooker investigation that pulls detectives into a layered probe built on overlapping relationships, buried secrets, and motive clusters that don’t cleanly align.

RELATED:   Parent Wars: Emergency Parenting (A&E, Tuesday, June 24, 2025)

Structured like much of the franchise’s slate, the hour moves fast through taped interrogations, surveillance pulls, and psychological tactics. Detectives pit suspects against each other in a closed-room play that slowly unearths a dynamic rooted in jealousy and betrayal.

New York Homicide leans on procedural storytelling with a tabloid edge—built for the network’s core base of crime-forward viewers who tune in for tight timelines, tough detectives, and a clean break to justice.

RELATED:   The Killer Clown: Murder on the Doorstep: Season Finale (SundanceTV, Thursday, June 19, 2025)

“The Coney Island Cover Up” airs Saturday, May 24 at 9 PM ET/PT on Oxygen True Crime.

Andrew Martins, reviewer, recapper, deep diver, scifi specialist. Thinks Blakes 7 is better than Star Trek. Yes I do go to fan conventions and no I don't dress up. Well okay maybe I do a bit.