Connect with us


Features

Classic TV Battles: Dr Finlay’s Casebook versus Emergency Ward 10

Published

on


The earliest medical media rivalry in the UK must be between Dr Finlay’s Casebook and Emergency Ward 10.

Doctor Finlay’s Casebook
Dr Finlay was loosely based on stories by author A.J. Cronin about a general practitioner from the 1920s in the rural (and fictitious) Scottish village of Tannochbrae. The Arden House surgery staff consisted of crusty old Dr Cameron, played by fine Scots actor Andrew Cruickshank, and young, dashing Dr Finlay, played by former TV newsreader Bill Simpson. Their ministering angel was the saintly housekeeper Janet, played by Barbara Mullen.

The series was originally thrown together in five weeks to fill a five week gap in the BBC’s schedules… and lasted in an almost unbroken run until the early 1970s. It also existed for a long while as a radio drama, and then returned again in the early 1990s in a Scottish TV drama (with high production values but without, sadly, the inimitable Cruickshank, Simpson and Mullen. The cast of Emergency Ward 10.

Emergency Ward 10
The chief rival to Dr Finlay had already been running a while on ITV – Emergency Ward 10. Set in the imaginary city of Oxbridge in the English Midlands. This twice-weekly serial started in 1957, when a lowly writer suggested ‘something about doctors and nurses’ might fill a yawning gap in the schedules (is there a pattern emerging here?). The emergencies always took second place to the romantic lives of the doctors and nurses, and the number of deaths allowed per year was set at five (compared to E.R., which sometimes manages to clock up five deaths before you’ve even got as far as the opening titles).

Advertisement

An astounding range of British acting talent cut their teeth on Ward 10 – including Absolutely Fabulous star Joanna Lumley – and a movie was released starring Wilfred Hyde-White called Life in Emergency Ward 10. The series ran out of steam and viewers in 1967 – but was revived pretty much intact (different hospital, different stars, same stories!) as General Hospital in the early seventies.


Alastair James is the editor in chief for Memorable TV. He has been involved in media since his university days. Alastair is passionate about television, and some of his favourite shows include Line of Duty, Luther and Traitors. He is always on the lookout for hot new shows, and is always keen to share his knowledge with others.

Advertisement
The Valley on Hayu The Valley on Hayu
News35 seconds ago

Series Premiere, The Valley, March 19, 2024, Bravo,

Get ready for the series premiere of The Valley called “Welcome to the Valley” on Bravo, airing on Tuesday, March...

Road Wars Road Wars
News4 mins ago

Road Wars, March 19, 2024, A&E, “All Blocked Off”

Prepare for intense action in the upcoming episode of Road Wars, titled “All Blocked Off,” airing on A&E on Tuesday,...

Customer Wars Customer Wars
News4 mins ago

Customer Wars, March 19, 2024, A&E, “Homeowner vs. Handyman”

Prepare for unexpected confrontations and thrilling moments in Customer Wars’ upcoming episode titled “Homeowner vs. Handyman,” airing on A&E on...

Chopped Chopped
News5 mins ago

Chopped, March 19, 2024, Food Network, “Truffle Kerfuffle”

Food Network presents an exciting new episode of Chopped called “Truffle Kerfuffle” airing on Tuesday, March 19th at 8:00 PM....

Wildcard Kitchen Wildcard Kitchen
News6 mins ago

Wildcard Kitchen, March 19, 2024, Food Network, “Italian Night Out”

Get ready for an exciting and unpredictable culinary adventure on Food Network’s Wildcard Kitchen. In the upcoming episode titled “Italian...

Restoring Galveston Restoring Galveston
News7 mins ago

Restoring Galveston: The Inn, March 19, 2024, Magnolia, “Welcome Inn”

Magnolia Network invites viewers to witness the transformation of Michael and Ashley’s historic inn in an all-new episode of Restoring...

Fixer to Fabulous Fixer to Fabulous
News7 mins ago

Fixer to Fabulous: Italiano, March 19, 2024, HGTV, “Stone House Surprises”

Experience the allure of Italy through the eyes of Dave and Jenny Marrs as they return for an exciting episode...

Renovation Aloha Renovation Aloha
News8 mins ago

Renovation Aloha, March 19, 2024, HGTV, “Historic Hawaiian Finds”

Discover the vibrant world of house flipping in the stunning backdrop of Honolulu, Hawaii with Renovation Aloha. In the latest...

Great British Menu Great British Menu
News13 hours ago

The Finals: Starters, Great British Menu, 18 March 2024, BBC Two

Get ready for the brand new episode of Great British Menu, as national finals week kicks off with the starters...

Anton & Giovanni's Adventures in Spain Anton & Giovanni's Adventures in Spain
News13 hours ago

Series Premiere, Anton & Giovanni’s Adventures in Spain, 18 March 2024, BBC One

In the premiere episode of the brand new series “Anton & Giovanni’s Adventures in Spain,” Strictly Come Dancing stars Anton...

Panorama Panorama
News13 hours ago

Paying More for Less: Councils in Crisis, Panorama, 18 March 2024, BBC One

In the latest episode of Panorama, titled “Paying More for Less: Councils in Crisis,” viewers will be taken behind the...

Channel 4 Channel 4
News14 hours ago

Whites Only: Ade’s Extremist Adventure, 18 March 2024, Channel 4

In a thought-provoking and enlightening new documentary titled “Whites Only: Ade’s Extremist Adventure,” airing on Channel 4 on Monday 18...

Channel 4 Channel 4
News14 hours ago

24 Hours in A&E, 18 March 2024, Channel 4, “Season 32 Episode 3”

In the latest episode of Channel 4’s “24 HOURS IN A&E,” viewers are taken inside Queen’s Medical Centre in Nottingham,...

George Clarke's Remarkable Renovations George Clarke's Remarkable Renovations
News14 hours ago

Chiltern Hills Barber Shop, George Clarke’s Remarkable Renovations, 18 March 2024, Channel 4

In the latest episode of Channel 4’s “George Clarke’s Remarkable Renovations,” architect George Clarke continues to showcase the inspiring stories of...

Traffic Cops Traffic Cops
News14 hours ago

Traffic Cops, 18 March 2024, Channel 5, “Season 13, Episode 14”

In the latest episode of Channel 5’s “Traffic Cops,” viewers will once again be taken on a gripping journey alongside...

Channel 5 Channel 5
News14 hours ago

Coma Series Premiere, 18 March 2024, Channel 5

In the series premiere of the four part Channel 5 drama “Coma,” viewers are introduced to Simon, a devoted family...

Popular