Classic TV Battles: Young Dr Kildare versus Angry Ben Casey

Dr Kildare’s history stretches back to the forties, and serials on radio and in the cinema. The stories centres around a young doctor making his way in a large Californian hospital under the expert tutelage of crusty old Dr Gillespie. When the stories were transferred to NBC TV, the series was an almost instant hit, thanks in no small measure to Richard Chamberlain in the title role.

But the series was overtaken after a year by another medical series on the rival ABC network. Ben Casey was another kettle of fish altogether. Where Dr Kildare was bright and sunny, Ben Casey was dark and brooding. Dr Kildare had a laugh with the nurses whereas Dr Ben Casey was too busy with his angst.

In many ways, Ben Casey was the forerunner of today’s popular dramas, ER, Casualty and Chicago Hope. At the time, Time magazine reviewed the series saying it “accurately captures the feeling of sleepless intensity in a metropolitan hospital.” Ben Casey’s regular run-ins with authority and regular battles against the system made for occasionally uncomfortable but always unmissable viewing.

Vince Edwards died of pancreatic cancer in 1996 – a few years before he died, he recalled how the series’ success came as a total shock – as the series shot into the top ten shows, he was living in the spare room of a friend’s house, a far cry from the usual megastar’s abode.

Alastair James is the editor-in-chief of Memorable TV, leading the charge in covering today's must-see television. A lifelong television enthusiast, his passion began with a deep dive into the world of classic sci-fi, culminating in his role as editor of "Beyond the Static," a publication devoted to celebrating iconic sci-fi series. While his love for classic television remains, Alastair's focus at Memorable TV is firmly on the present, analyzing the latest trends in the television landscape, from gripping crime dramas to the ever-evolving strategies of Survivor. His insights have been featured in numerous publications. At Memorable TV, Alastair's goal is to provide readers with sharp commentary, engaging reviews, and in-depth analysis of the shows dominating the current conversation.