Connect with us


Musical Lifetimes – the golden age of musical biographies



Five Of The Best James Cagney Movies

Screen biographies of musicians might be expected to consist of strong story lines with musical interludes. Yet generally their plots are so frail and foolish that they provide no more than excuses for songs and dances. And it is perhaps flattering these films to suggest that they run to stories’ in the plural: some-how. Whatever the differences of temperament, background and talent among the musicians concerned, when it comes to the cinematic point they all seem to have led very similar lives.

Male musicians are portrayed as having humble origins: their early struggles are compensated for by a sober, loving, home-life; they become swollen-headed by success and then entangled with a glamorous star or rich socialite. but are rescued from the brink of disaster by the love of a good, mousy wife who helps them make a fresh start.

Success always comes early for female musicians: they are unable to cope with it and turn rapidly to drink or drugs: they have a disastrous romantic involvement and are then crippled by an accident or afflicted with illness: eventually, however, they find the will to go on and come up smiling.

Studio Whitewash

The advantage of these simple plots is that the tried-and-true hit songs may easily be fitted in. These numbers would frequently be performed by an all-star cast, which could be assembled quite cheaply since each star would only be employed for a very brief period in the film. It is hard to say which studio first hit on this formula, but probably the best claim belongs to Warner Brothers with Yankee Doodle Dandy – the life of George M. Cohan – in 1942.

Since Cohan was alive at the time, the film could hardly hint that he had any personality defects whatever, except a touch of Irish temper from time to time. James Cagney, the star, aroused audience sympathy and the film made a very successful addition to the studio’s long series of rather literary biographical films of the Thirties, such as The Story of Louis Pasteur (1936) and The Life of Emille Zola (1937). They were thus encouraged to try again and in 1945 brought out Rhapsody in Blue, an anodyne life of George Gershwin, and in the following year Night and Day, a life of Cole Porter starring Cary Grant.

Night and Day

Cole Porter as played by Cary Grant in Night and Day

After Night and Day, Warners made only one more composer biography, I’ll See You In My Dreams (1952), in which Danny Thomas as Gus Kahn and Doris Day as his sweetly sensible wife ran through every cliché in the book. MGM made tributes to Kern (1946, Til the Clouds Roll By), Rodgers and Hart (1948, Words and Music) and Kalmar and Ruby (1950, Three Little Words) – all of them all-star revues with a bit of plot, which consisted of variations on the usual theme, to ‘hold the numbers apart’.

20th Century Fox took virtually the only remaining team – De Sylva, Brown and Henderson – as the subjeets of The Best Things in Life Are Free (1956), by then studios had begun to concentrate on performers. Following The Jolson Story (1946) and Jolson Sings Again (1949), came The Glenn Miller Story (1953), The Benny Goodman Story (1955) and The Gene Krupa Story (1959). Lillian Roth was shown hitting the bottle in I’ll Cry Tomorrow (1955) as was Helen Morgan in The Helen Morgan Story (1957), Ruth Etting loved a gangster in Love Me or Leave Me (1955): Jane Froman was crippled in With a Song in My Heart (1952) as was opera star Marjorie Lawrence in Interrupted Melody (1955), but somehow, they all sang on . .

Doris Day Love Me Or Leave Me

Doris Day played Ruth Etting in Love Me Or Leave Me.

The singer not the song

These famous suffering ladies. of course, provided great vehicles, mostly for leading ladies who specialized in playing suffering women – like Eleanor Parker and Susan Hayward. Ann Blyth did not help her career by playing Helen Morgan, but the role of Ruth Etting initialed a new stage in Doris Day’s career.

It was easier to make a performer the centre of a musical biography than a composer; apart from Cary Grant as Cole Porter, composers in films tended lo sit on the sidelines of the drama while their songs were performed by others; consequently, composers were usually played by stars of the second rank.

An exception was Glenn Miller, played with laconic charm by James Stewart: Miller’s rags-to-riches story was more interesting than most and he also had the advantage, from the dramatic point of view, of dying in an air crash during World War II.

If the studio felt that the subjeci of a screen biography lacked the requisite box-office pull, it drafted in star names to boost the film’s appeal.

Audiences were encouraged to see Lillian Russell (1940) because she was played by Alice Faye and Incendiary Blonde (1945). a biography of Texas Guinan, because it starred Betty Hutton. The same, applied to The Dolly Sisters (1945), reincarnated by Betty Grable and June Haver, and The I Don’t Care Girl (1952), which cast Mitzi Gaynor as Eva Tanguay. All these films were firmly modelled around the lineaments of their respective stars.

Funny Girl

Barbara Streisand in Funny Girl.

This formula worked well while stars like these commanded big followings. But after the Fifties, there were fewer and fewer names that ensured box-oflice success simply by virtue of their presence in a film. People wanted to see their favourite star in the right kind of role in the right kind of movie. Most of the (few) female superstars of recent years have tried at least one biography: Julie Andrews took the part of Gertrude Lawrence in Star! (1968), Diana Ross became Billie Holiday in Lady Sings the Blues (1972), Barbra Streisand played Fanny Brice in Funny Girl in 1968 and in Funny Lady (1975), and Bette Midler was a renamed but recognisable Janis Joplin in The Rose (1979).

Of these, one was a spectacular and significant failure. Funny Girl, Lady Sings the Blues and The Rose all have strong dramatic stories which do not seriously depend on audiences’ knowing anything about the characters on which they were based. Star! had no story at all – no drama, no noticeable romance, nothing which would answer the question audiences were bound to ask as to why they should be expected to spend three and a quarter hours in the company of its somewhat chilly main attraction.



Mayans MC: Perro O/C Series Premiere 4 Sep on FXMayans MC: Perro O/C Series Premiere 4 Sep on FX
Episodes12 mins ago

Mayans MC: Perro O/C Series Premiere 4 Sep on FX

The Sons of Anarchy spin-off kicks off with series opener Perro/OC whereEZ’s fate is in flux as the M.C. and...

Law and Disorder (1958, Michael Redgrave, Lionel Jeffries)Law and Disorder (1958, Michael Redgrave, Lionel Jeffries)
Movies4 hours ago

Law and Disorder (1958, Michael Redgrave, Lionel Jeffries)

In Law and Disorder, loveable conman Percy Brand (Michael Redgrave) has always managed to hide his shameful profession from beloved...

The Fourth Estate (Showtime 2018, Maggie Haberman, Arthur Gregg Sulzberger)The Fourth Estate (Showtime 2018, Maggie Haberman, Arthur Gregg Sulzberger)
TV4 hours ago

The Fourth Estate (Showtime 2018, Maggie Haberman, Arthur Gregg Sulzberger)

The Fourth Estate is an excellent four part documentary exploring the process and progress of The New York Times and...

Better Call Saul: Quite A Ride (AMC 3 Sep 2018)Better Call Saul: Quite A Ride (AMC 3 Sep 2018)
Episodes5 hours ago

Better Call Saul: Quite A Ride (AMC 3 Sep 2018)

Quite a Ride: Jimmy identifies a new market for his talents. Mike vets a potential partnership. Kim drives a hard...

Strange Angel (CBSAA 2018, Jack Reynor, Rupert Friend, Strange Angel (CBSAA 2018, Jack Reynor, Rupert Friend, 
TV6 hours ago

Strange Angel (CBSAA 2018, Jack Reynor, Rupert Friend,

Strange Angel, a drama series created by Mark Heyman (“Black Swan,” “The Skeleton Twins”) and based on George Pendle’s book...

Carry On Jack (1963, Jim Dale, Juliet Mills)Carry On Jack (1963, Jim Dale, Juliet Mills)
Movies6 hours ago

Carry On Jack (1963, Jim Dale, Juliet Mills)

‘Twas on the good ship Venus, commanded by Captain Fearless (Kenneth Williams), that midshipman Albert Poop-Decker (Bernard Cribbins) found himself...

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: The Disappearing Game (HMC 2018, Candace Cameron Bure)Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: The Disappearing Game (HMC 2018, Candace Cameron Bure)
TV7 hours ago

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: The Disappearing Game (HMC 2018, Candace Cameron Bure)

In The Disappearing Game crime-solving librarian Aurora Teagarden leaps headfirst into Lawrenceton’s latest murder investigation when her nephew Phillip and...

Marooned (1969, Gregory Peck, Richard Crenna)Marooned (1969, Gregory Peck, Richard Crenna)
Movies7 hours ago

Marooned (1969, Gregory Peck, Richard Crenna)

In Marooned, after five months in space, the manned space mission Ironman One is ready to return. But a failed...

Time Bandits (1981, Michael Palin, Sean Connery)Time Bandits (1981, Michael Palin, Sean Connery)
Movies7 hours ago

Time Bandits (1981, Michael Palin, Sean Connery)

Terry Gilliam’s extraordinary fantasy Time Bandits begins calmly enough for young Craig Warnock, trapped in a dull suburban existence with his parents...